The Magnitsky List (also known as the Cardin List ) is a list of persons according to the position of its compilers responsible for the detention, ill-treatment and death of the auditor Sergei Magnitsky , other gross violations of human rights in the Russian Federation, and a series of major embezzlement of funds from the Russian budget under the guise of a tax refund disclosed by a group of lawyers and auditors, including Magnitsky.
The list is named for US Senator Benjamin Cardin , who, together with Rep. James McGovern , appealed to US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton on April 26, 2010 to impose a series of personal sanctions against these people [1] with an attached list of names.
Initially, the list contained 60 names of officials of the Ministry of Internal Affairs , the FSB , the Federal Tax Service , the Arbitration Court , the General Prosecutor's Office and the FSIN , as well as a brief description of the role of each of these persons in the Hermitage Capital case and in the prosecution of Sergei Magnitsky [2] . In the future, when various normative acts were adopted on the basis of the initiatives of Kardin and other people in different countries, the number of people in them sometimes differed from the initial list.
Content
Background
In 2007, 5.4 billion rubles were stolen from the Russian budget, which is considered the largest one-time theft of funds from the state budget of Russia in history [3] . The first to discover this crime were employees of Firestone Duncan, which served the legal interests of the Hermitage Capital Management investment fund, among which were Eduard Khairetdinov, Vladimir Pastukhov, Jamison Firestone and Sergey Magnitsky [4] . They initiated an investigation into the embezzlement of budget funds, within the framework of which the list of participants in the crime became obvious, including several dozen employees of various Russian executive authorities.
On November 24, 2008, Sergei Magnitsky was arrested on charges of assisting the head of the Hermitage Capital Management Fund, William Browder, in tax evasion. After 11 months of pre-trial detention, Sergei died in the hospital of Detention Center No. 1 in Moscow. The initiator of his arrest and investigator in his case turned out to be key participants in the theft revealed by Sergey and his colleagues.
In April 2010, Senator Benjamin Cardin asked Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to close the US visa corridor for 60 Russian officials involved in this theft and in Sergei’s death. In May of that year, the family of the late S. Magnitsky received official condolences from President Barack Obama . In September 2010, the US Congress voted in favor of Cardin’s initiative. The European Parliament did the same in December.
Legislative Recognition List
On December 16, 2010, the European Parliament voted in favor of a resolution calling for the ban on entry to EU countries by Russian officials involved in the case of Sergei Magnitsky. The resolution is not binding, but recommends that governments of the EU countries study the possibility of visa and financial sanctions against persons mentioned in documents related to the Magnitsky case [5] .
In the American Congress, the initiative of Cardin and Makover was considered under the name of English. Sergei Magnitsky Rule of Law Accountability Act of 2012 [6] . The future law was drafted so that the executive authorities of the United States at any time had the opportunity to add and remove people from the "List ...": it "will be open for replenishment, but closed to the public" [7] .
In September 2012, it became known that Britain had already enacted its “Magnitsky Act” [8] [9] . Then it became known that the introduction of sanctions within the countries provided for by the “Magnitsky law” was proposed by the deputies of Sweden and the Netherlands [10] . In addition to the USA and Great Britain, the authorities of Canada, Poland and Estonia spoke about their readiness to join the sanctions against Sergey’s killers at different times [8] .
In December 2012, US President Barack Obama signed into English. Russia and Moldova Jackson-Vanik Repeal and Sergei Magnitsky Rule of Law Accountability Act of 2012 , known as the Magnitsky Act , creating a mechanism that allows the US Secretary of State to include any foreign corrupt officials and criminals in the sanctions list without the consent of Congress. The first 18 people were officially listed on April 12, 2013.
List
Below is a list of people in Cardin's original list. It was published in April 2010 on the website of the American Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe ] [ 1] [11] which was then chaired by Ben Cardin. The list contains the names of Russian officials and a brief description of the role of each of them in the Magnitsky case. [12] [13]
| No. | Name | Position | Department |
|---|---|---|---|
| one | Alexey Anichin | Former Deputy Head of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation - Head of the IC Ministry of Internal Affairs | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| 2 | Oleg Logunov | Head of the Legal Department of the General Prosecutor's Office, previously Deputy Head of the Investigative Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs | Prosecutor General's Office |
| 3 | Oleg Silchenko | Investigation Team Leader | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| four | Alexander Matveev | Deputy Head of the Ministry of Internal Affairs | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| five | Gennady Karlov | Head of Department | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| 6 | Natalya Vinogradova | Deputy Head of Department | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| 7 | Alexander Ryabinin | Investigator | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| eight | Sergey Oleinik | Investigator | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| 9 | A. A. Malygina | Investigator | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| ten | M.O. Sapunova | Investigator | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| eleven | E.V. Mikhailov | Investigator | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| 12 | R. A. Gritsay | Investigator | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| 13 | I. A. Varganov | Investigator | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| 14 | Nelly Dmitrieva | Investigator | GUVD of Moscow |
| 15 | Artyom Kuznetsov | Employee of the Office for the Fight against Tax Crimes (Deputy Head of Division 6), now the Ministry of Internal Affairs | GUVD of Moscow |
| sixteen | Alexey Droganov | Employee of the Office for Combating Tax Crimes (subordinate of Kuznetsov) | GUVD of Moscow |
| 17 | Dmitry Tolchinsky | Officer of the Office for Combating Tax Crimes (employee of the 6th Division) | GUVD of Moscow |
| 18 | A. A. Krechetov | Officer of the Office for Combating Tax Crimes (employee of the 6th Division) | GUVD of Moscow |
| nineteen | Alexander Klevtsov | Officer of the Office for Combating Tax Crimes (Head of Division 6) | GUVD of Moscow |
| 20 | Anatoly Mikhailin | Head of the Office of Tax Crimes (dismissed) | GUVD of Moscow |
| 21 | Pavel Karpov | Investigator of the Main Investigative Department | GUVD of Moscow |
| 22 | Ivan Glukhov | Head of the Main Investigative Department of the Central Internal Affairs Directorate in Moscow (dismissed) | GUVD of Moscow |
| 23 | Nikolay Budilo | Investigator | SC Ministry of Internal Affairs |
| 24 | Oleg Urzhumtsev | Investigator | Investigative Department of the UPC in the Republic of Tatarstan |
| 25 | Alexander Kuvaldin | Employee, Office K, Economic Security Service | FSB of the Russian Federation |
| 26 | Victor Voronin | Head of Department "K" of the Economic Security Service | FSB of the Russian Federation |
| 27 | Stanislav Gordeevsky | The prosecutor | Moscow prosecutor's office |
| 28 | Natalya Yakimovich | Prosecutor, Deputy Head of the Department for CAO of Moscow | Moscow prosecutor's office |
| 29th | Sergey Lazutkin | Prosecutor, Head of the Department for CAO of Moscow | Moscow prosecutor's office |
| thirty | Arkady Mazhaev | Head of Anti-Corruption Procedural Control Department | SKP RF |
| 31 | Alexander Burov | The prosecutor | Prosecutor General's Office |
| 32 | Andrey Pechegin | Head of Department | Prosecutor General's Office |
| 33 | Victor Grin | Deputy Attorney General | Prosecutor General's Office |
| 34 | Elena Himina | Head of Tax Inspectorate 25 | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 35 | Sergey Zhemchuzhnikov | Deputy Head of the Tax Inspectorate 25 | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 36 | Raisa Burmistrova | Head of Tax Debt Department (Inspection 25) | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 37 | Alexandra Kuznetsova | Head of Department (Inspection 25) | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 38 | Julia Koltunova | Head of Tax Audit Department (Inspection 25) | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 39 | Olga Stepanova | Head of Tax (Inspection 28) | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 40 | Olga Tsumai | Head of Tax Audit Department (Inspection 28) | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 41 | Svetlana Dubrovskaya | Head of Tax Audit Department (Inspection 28) | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 42 | Olga Davydova | Head of Tax Debt Department (Inspection 28) | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 43 | Ekaterina Frolova | Head of Division (Inspection 28) | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 44 | Olesya Shargorodskaya | Inspection Officer 28 | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 45 | Maxim Tretyakov | Head of Legal Department of Inspection 28 | Moscow Federal Tax Service |
| 46 | Ivan Prokopenko | Head of the pre-trial detention center | Pre-trial detention center "Sailor silence" |
| 47 | Dmitry Komnov | Head of the pre-trial detention center (currently the head of the pre-trial detention center No. 3 of the Federal Penitentiary Service of Moscow) | Butyrsky pre-trial detention center |
| 48 | Dmitry Kratov | Deputy head of the Butyrka detention center for medical and preventive work | Butyrsky pre-trial detention center |
| 49 | Larisa Litvinova | Head of the medical department of the Butyrka pre-trial detention center | Butyrsky pre-trial detention center |
| 50 | Sergey Podoprigorov | Judge | Tverskoy District Court of Moscow |
| 51 | Alexey Krivoruchko | Judge | Tverskoy District Court of Moscow |
| 52 | Svetlana Ukhnaleva | Judge | Tverskoy District Court of Moscow |
| 53 | Elena Stashina | Judge | Tverskoy District Court of Moscow |
| 54 | Galina Filippova | Judge | Tverskoy District Court of Moscow |
| 55 | Tatyana Korneeva | Judge | Simonovsky District Court of Moscow |
| 56 | Rufina Gazizova | Judge | Vakhitovsky District Court of Kazan |
| 57 | Andrey Yushkov | Judge | Arbitration Court of Tatarstan |
| 58 | Elena Kim | Judge | Moscow Arbitration Court |
| 59 | Ildar Salimzyanov | Judge | Arbitration Court of Tatarstan |
| 60 | Margarita Zinurova | Since September 18, 2007 - Deputy Chairman of the Arbitration Court | Arbitration Court of the Moscow Region |
Subsequent Updates to the List
In the resolution of the European Parliament of December 16, 2010, the list of Cardin was supplemented by another character - judge Arthur Karpov .
On April 12, 2013, the United States added two persons unrelated to the Magnitsky case to its list:
- Lecha Bogatyryov, suspected of killing Umar Israilov (former bodyguard of Ramzan Kadyrov ).
- Kazbek Dukuzov, suspected of murder in Moscow of the chief editor of the Russian Forbes publication Paul Khlebnikov .
In April 2014, the European Parliament adopted another resolution - a ban on entry into the EU countries and the freezing of European assets (if any) 32 persons who, according to European deputies, are directly responsible for the death of Sergei Magnitsky [14] .
In January 2017, the list included:
- Alexander Bastrykin ;
- Stanislav Gordievsky;
- Dmitry Kovtun;
- Andrey Lugovoi ;
- Gennady Plaksin. [15]
On December 20, 2017, Ramzan Kadyrov was added to the list, as well as the head of the Argun police department Ayub Kataev, who was called involved in the persecution and torture of gays in Chechnya in 2017. Also on the list were some Julia Mayorova, Andrei Pavlov, Alexei Sheshenya. [sixteen]
On December 21, the son of the Prosecutor General of Russia, Artyom Chaika, was put on the list with the wording for using the position of his father to unfairly win government contracts, receive state assets and to influence business competitors [17] .
Notes
- ↑ 1 2 Benjamin L. Cardin, Alcee L. Hastings. CARDIN URGES VISA BAN FOR RUSSIAN OFFICIALS CONNECTED TO ANTI-CORRUPTION LAWYER'S DEATH (inaccessible link) . U.S. Government Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe - Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe (April 26, 2010). Date of treatment December 29, 2012. Archived March 4, 2016.
- ↑ The investigator who planted Magnitsky spends a million dollars a year, found out by the colleagues of the deceased lawyer . NEWSru (June 23, 2010). Date of treatment August 13, 2010. Archived March 4, 2012.
- ↑ Masha Hesse. William Browder: There is no state in Russia (Rus.) = Interview with William Browder, head of the Hermitage Capital investment fund // Snob. - 2011.
- ↑ Ivan Prosvetov. Sergei Magnitsky was offered a deal with the investigation (rus.) = Lawyers for a lawyer who died in a pre-trial detention center told Forbes how everything really happened // Forbes. - 2009.
- ↑ BBC: “The European Parliament approved a resolution in the Magnitsky case”
- ↑ HR 4405: Sergei Magnitsky Rule of Law Accountability Act of 2012 . Date of treatment September 4, 2012.
- ↑ The Magnitsky List will be open for replenishment and closed to the public (inaccessible link) (06/20/2012). Date of treatment September 4, 2012. Archived December 4, 2012.
- ↑ 1 2 The death of Magnitsky - Great Britain forbade the persons involved in the "Magnitsky list" from entering the country - Newspaper. Ru
- ↑ Russian officials from the Magnitsky list are not allowed to enter Britain (inaccessible link) . Date of treatment November 1, 2014. Archived February 2, 2014.
- ↑ Kommersant Newspaper - London endorsed the Magnitsky list
- ↑ Individuals involved in tax fraud against Hermitage and the Torture and Death of Sergei Magnitsky . www.csce.gov . CSCE (April 26, 2010).
- ↑ Benjamin_Cardin_and_Alexey_Socnev. The list of perpetrators of the death of Magnitsky . samlib.ru. Date of treatment July 3, 2018.
- ↑ Cardin Urges Visa Ban for Russian Officials Connected to Anti-Corruption Lawyer's Death (English) , CSCE (February 23, 2016). Contact date July 3, 2018. “The 60 names on the list include senior officials from the Russian Interior Ministry, Federal Security Service, Federal Tax Service, Arbitration Courts, General Prosecutor Office, and Federal Prison Service, along with detailed descriptions of their involvement in the case. ".
- ↑ The European Parliament adopted the Magnitsky List.
- ↑ Magnitsky-related Designations; Counter Terrorism Designations . www.treasury.gov. Date of treatment January 10, 2017.
- ↑ The United States put Ramzan Kadyrov on the Magnitsky list (Russian) , Meduza . Date of treatment December 20, 2017.
- ↑ The United States imposed sanctions against the son of Attorney General Artyom Chaika
Links
- The European Parliament adopted the Magnitsky List . Novaya Gazeta (April 3, 2014). Date of treatment March 31, 2015.