Authentic (authentic) interpretation of law - a type of interpretation of the rule of law ; It is an explanation of the rule of law given by the authority that issued them. Authentic interpretation of legal norms is characterized by a direct explanation of the meaning of legal norms and is binding on those who apply them. It is a means of filling the gaps in the legislation and the most authoritative type of interpretation [1] .
Content
The meaning of authentic interpretation
The results of an authentic interpretation have the same legal force as the interpreted norm itself; they are drawn up in a clearly expressed form (agreement, declaration, communiqué) or are reflected in agreed practice [1] .
Worldwide Application
Among Russian legal scholars there is no unity regarding the existence of an authentic interpretation in Russia. So, according to the doctor of legal sciences , professor Natalia Lopashenko , at present, the Constitution of the Russian Federation does not provide for the possibility of an authentic interpretation of any laws, including criminal [2] . Doctor of Law , Professor Vladimir Sergeevich Komissarov, and Candidate of Law , Professor , Honored Lawyer of the Russian Federation Anatoly Pavlukhin, who give a simple example from the criminal law, note 1 to article 158 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation , which they consider is a clear example of an authentic interpretation [3] . Doctor of Law , Professor Alexei G. Kibalnik believes that the authentic interpretation is carried out by the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation . Also, in his opinion, an authentic interpretation is binding and, in essence, is a change in the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation [4] .
See also
- Interpretation of law
Notes
- ↑ 1 2 Lukashuk I.I. Chapter VII. Application of international law // International law. General part: a textbook for students of law faculties and universities / Ros. Acad. Sciences , Institute of State and Law , Academ. legal university - 3rd edition, revised and supplemented. - M .: Walters Clover, 2008 .-- S. 236. - 432 p. - (Series "Student Library"). - 2 thousand copies - ISBN 978-5-466-00103-7 .
- ↑ Lopashenko N.A. Chapter 5. Criminal Law // Introduction to Criminal Law: A Training Manual / Reviewers: Dr. jur. sciences , prof. S. A. Eliseev; Cand. legal Sciences , Assoc. M.V. Feoklistov. - M .: Walters Clover, 2009 .-- S. 198. - 224 p. - 2 thousand copies - ISBN 978-5-466-00427-4 .
- ↑ Komissarov V. S., Pavlukhin A. N., Perov I. F., Rastoropov S. V., Chistyakov A. A. Chapter 3. Criminal Law // Criminal Law. General part: Textbook / Reviewers: A. S. Mikhlin ( Doctor of Law , Professor ), V. I. Starkov ( Doctor of Law , Professor ). - SPb. : Publishing House " Peter ", 2003. - S. 31. - 240 p. - (Series "Textbook"). - 4 thousand copies - ISBN 5-94723-572-2 .
- ↑ Adelkhanyan R. A., Aminov D. I., Ansimov Yu. N. Chapter 2. Criminal law and its interpretation // Criminal law of Russia. Practical course: textbook. allowance: textbook. for university students enrolled in the specialty "Jurisprudence" / under the general. ed. A.I. Bastrykin; under the scientific. ed. A.V. Naumova. - 3rd edition, revised and supplemented. - M .: Walters Clover, 2007 .-- S. 38. - 808 p. - 5 thousand copies. - ISBN 978-5-466-00282-9 .
Literature
- Kolokolov Ya. N. Authentic interpretation of legal acts: the search for new paradigms. - M .: Yurlitinform, 2010 .-- 376 p. - ISBN 978-5-93295-637-3 .
- Kolokolov Y. N. Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation: Authentic Interpretation of Decisions as a Form of Lawmaking // Russian Judge. - 2009. - No. 12. - S. 45-48.
- Kolokolov Y. N. Problems of Authentic Interpretation of Normative Legal Acts in the Works of Russian Scientists of the Pre-Revolutionary Period // History of State and Law. - 2010. - No. 2. - P. 45–48.